Allright, I'm starting something new here (besides actually POSTING here!!)...a series...
Double Albums That Should Have Been Single Albums!I know I'll get a bit of flack over this (and I have), but...
The Beatles- The Beatles (a.ka. The White Album)Ok, my friend Mike and I have been debating which songs should be cut off this one to make it a single album. (
NOTE: Mike dosent agree with me that
ANY of the songs should be cut off- he wanted me to let you know that. )If you're talking 1968 standard album length, then there's going to be alot of cutting. If you're talking standard 2005 CD length, it makes it a bit easier...
We both agree- the first one to be cut would be "
Back in the USSR"- what an annoying song that is anyway. "
Birthday"- buh-bye! Another really annoying song that I skip whenever the White Album is in the CD player (you know, CD's actually are great because of the "skip" button!). "
Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da" gets the axe too (seems like a McCartney filler junk tune to me!).
The first three were the easiest, the other songs, all have great parts, and I could go back and forth on which songs to keep or which ones to cut on several:
Why Don't We do it in the Road? (cool sounding, but really a meaningless song)
I WillWild Honey Pie (gets points for weirdness)
Honey Pie (loss of the weirdness point here)
Long, Long, Long (the title says it all!)
Cry Baby CryRocky Raccoon (allright, a killer song, but maybe should have been on one of Paul's solo albums)
Martha My Dear (nice, but a little hokey)
Piggies (great instrumentation, but a little hokey- gets points though for the lyric "What they need is a damn good whacking")
I think that "
Revolution #9" should have been cut, or perhaps placed on the "B-Side" list. Please, do we really need this? Definately gets points for the backwards stuff though!
All in all, "
The Beatles" is a great album, though I think it's all over the map musically, and you can see the band going in their different directions. In my opinion, the best work in the later Beatles' catalog is "
Abbey Road", and they avoided the filler crap they fell into when assembling this album.
...stay tuned for the next part in my series!!!